“The biggest challenge in the NFL is to handle success and handle failure. You have to stay consistent in your preparation and your approach,” said a star quarterback in November last year, sounding like someone who’d just stepped out of a Ted Lasso episode—all optimism and grit. But these days, the Indianapolis Colts aren’t just handling failure; they’re juggling it like a hot potato. With veteran QB Joe Flacco’s arm aging faster than a Twilight vampire and rookie Anthony Richardson’s flashes of brilliance clouded by inconsistency, head coach Shane Steichen is eyeing a $160 million curveball:
Former Giants QB Daniel Jones. Let’s rewind the tape. Jones, the once-heralded Duke product, entered the league in 2019 like a kid who’d won a golden ticket—only to find himself in a chocolate factory run by gremlins. His stats? A mixed bag of jaw-dropping highs and facepalm lows: 14,582 career passing YDs, 70 TDs, 47 INTs, and a sneaky 2,179 rushing YDs (including a Madden-esque 708 YDs in 2022).
The #Colts also have a lot of interest in former #Giants QB Daniel Jones to add competition. pic.twitter.com/kQUQdJCEyj
— NFL Rumors (@nflrums) March 3, 2025
But after a 24-44-1 record as a starter, the Giants cut him loose in November 2024. Now, the Colts see potential in his dual-threat chaos. “I’m absolutely one of the top QBs in the NFL,” Jones declared in 2023—a quote that aged like milk but still hints at the swagger Steichen craves.
Imagine Jones in horseshoe blue, scrambling like Forrest Gump with a playbook. His 2022 playoff win over the Vikings? Poetry in motion. His infamous 80-yard sprint against the Eagles? Pure slapstick.
Yet, Indy’s brass thinks he’s worth the gamble. “I gave everything I had… I’m excited for the next opportunity,” Jones said post-release, sounding more like a rom-com lead than a QB fighting for relevance. With Flacco’s 2024 stats (12 TDs, 7 INTs, 90.5 rating) failing to spark joy, Steichen’s playbook reads: “Out with the old, in with the… slightly less old?”
But here’s the twist: Jones isn’t just a reclamation project. He’s a $40 million man with Nike deals and a chip on his shoulder. His 2023 Giants extension—$160M, $82M guaranteed—was a Hail Mary that fell short. Now, he’s auditioning for a redemption arc. For the Colts, a low-risk, high-reward flier on Jones could either resurrect their QB room or become the NFL’s next “The Room”—so bad it’s legendary.
Eagles’ Super Bowl shuffle: Slay-Steichen’s Indy connection
Meanwhile, in a parallel universe where defense wins championships, the Colts are eyeing another Philly phenom: cornerback Darius Slay. Fresh off a Super Bowl LIX win with the Eagles, Slay’s release this March sent shockwaves—and Indy’s secondary perked up like a dog hearing a can opener. Last season, the Colts’ pass defense ranked 26th (229.4 YDs/game), a dumpster fire that made The Hunger Games look like a tea party. Enter Slay: six Pro Bowls, a 2017 INT crown (8 picks), and a flair for theatrics. “I like to compete. I like the one-on-one competition,” he growled in 2022.
Slay’s resume reads like a defensive highlight reel: an 83-YD fumble TD vs. Denver, clutch picks against Matthew Stafford (“Calm the [expletive] down!” he joked post-game), and a swagger that could fill Lucas Oil Stadium. At 34, he’s no spring chicken, but his 67.6 PFF grade last year beats watching rookies get torched weekly. Plus, Steichen’s Eagles ties add spice—this isn’t just business; it’s reunion season.
But let’s not forget: Indy’s a town where football is religion, and the Colts’ lore runs deeper. From Johnny Unitas’ “Greatest Game Ever Played” in ‘58 to Peyton Manning’s laser-rocket arm, this franchise thrives on reinvention. Relocating from Baltimore in ‘84? Bold. Hosting the NFL Scouting Combine since ‘87? Genius. Now, as they flirt with Jones and Slay, it’s another chapter in their “adapt or die” saga.
Picture this: Slay mentoring young CBs JuJu Brents and Jaylon Jones over Skyline Chili, while Daniel Jones battles Richardson in a QB duel narrated by Friday Night Lights’ Coach Taylor. It’s messy, it’s hopeful, and it’s so Colts. Because in Indy, every off-season feels like drafting a new hero—or a tragicomic antihero.
Epilogue: The Chessboard Awaits
Steichen’s masterplan? Swap Flacco’s fading magic for Jones’s untapped chaos, then anchor the defense with Slay’s savvy. Will it work? Who knows? But in the NFL, hope is the ultimate currency—and the Colts are cashing in. As Jones once said, “You have to stay consistent.” Or, as Slay might add, “Let’s ride.” Game on.
The post NFL Rumors: Shane Steichen Wants $160M QB to Replace Joe Flacco As Colts Target Eagles’ Super Bowl Winner appeared first on EssentiallySports.
