Imagine a seasoned pitcher eyeing the bullpen mid-game, itching for a change even as his manager signals to stay put. The crowd buzzes with speculation, but the playbook stays closed. In the NFL, quarterbacks don’t often pivot mid-contract—unless your name is Derek Carr. The 11-year veteran’s recent offseason moves felt less like a play call and more like a mystery novel missing its final chapter.
Carr’s career has mirrored a NASCAR race: long stretches of steady control, sudden pit stops for injuries, and the occasional bump from rivals. But this spring, the Saints’ QB took a detour that left even die-hard fans scratching their helmets. Rumors swirled—something was off in the Big Easy.
According to ESPN reports, Derek Carr’s camp quietly gauged interest from multiple QB-needy teams before his retirement bombshell. A Saints source confirmed Carr’s reps made indirect contact, testing the waters without written permission. “Outside talks never reached a serious point,” one Jeremy Fowler and Katherine Terrell noted, but the message was clear: Carr was window-shopping. Why?
Lingering tensions over coaching changes and contract restructures brewed beneath his stoic demeanor. New Orleans downplayed the chatter, with a team source shrugging, “[He] had earned the right to evaluate his future” (per ESPN). But behind closed doors, the Saints scrambled. Rookie coach Kellen Moore faced a media grilling just hours after Carr’s retirement, dodging questions like a Barry Sanders juke. The QB’s abrupt exit—blamed on a torn labrum and “degenerative rotator cuff”—left more questions than a halftime deficit.
Oct 8, 2023; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr (4) runs off of the field after a game against the New England Patriots during the second half at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brian Fluharty-USA TODAY Sports
Carr’s final act in New Orleans was pure drama. He threw for 2,145 yards and 15 TDs in 2024, battling oblique strains, concussions, and a fractured hand. But the shoulder injury? That blindsided everyone. Scans showed significant damage, the Saints revealed. Carr opted to walk away from $30 million rather than endure another rehab marathon. His farewell statement echoed gratitude, but whispers of “What if?” lingered like a halftime hot dog line.
The Saints, meanwhile, pivot to Plan B: a QB room of rookie Tyler Shough, Spencer Rattler, and Jake Haener. It’s a far cry from Carr’s veteran poise. “The draft was always the most logical play,” a team source admitted. However, drafting Shough over Shedeur Sanders raised eyebrows—a Hail Mary pass with no sure hands in sight.
The unanswered questions surrounding Carr’s exit
Carr’s exit wasn’t just about health. His $150 million deal had become an albatross. By retiring, he saved the Saints $30 million in cash but left a $69 million cap hit scattered like Mardi Gras beads. “Integrity matters to him,” a source close to Carr insisted, yet skeptics wonder if the shoulder was a convenient exit ramp.
The Saints’ front office, known for moving slower than a Superdome concession line, now faces a reboot. GM Mickey Loomis, 68, clings to win-now mode, re-signing aging stars like Cam Jordan. But without Carr, the offense leans on a ground game—a strategy as risky as a fourth-and-long in the red zone.
Sport Themen der Woche KW10 Sport Bilder des Tages NFL, American Football Herren, USA New Orleans Saints-Derek Carr press conference, PK, Pressekonferenz Mar 11, 2023 Metairie, LA, USA New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr with wife Heather Carr, daughter Brooklyn Carr and sons Dallas Carr, Deakon Carr and Deker Carr at Ochsner Sports Performance Center. Metairie Ochsner Sports Performance Center LA USA, EDITORIAL USE ONLY PUBLICATIONxINxGERxSUIxAUTxONLY Copyright: xStephenxLewx 20230311_cec_la1_046
Carr retires 20th all-time in passing yards (41,245) and touchdowns (257), yet his 0-1 playoff record stings. He played through pain like a gladiator, but the toll finally won. As philosopher Seneca once said, “Every new beginning comes from some other beginning’s end.” For Carr, was this an exit or an escape? And for the Saints, does Shough herald hope or another decade in QB purgatory?
Derek Carr’s career ends not with a Lombardi lift but a shoulder sling. His flirtation with other teams was perhaps a last gasp for relevance or a veteran reading the room. As New Orleans turns to untested arms, one question lingers. In a league obsessed with rings, does loyalty ever really win? Steve Jobs once said, “You can’t connect the dots looking forward; you can only connect them looking backward.” So, Saints fans: Is this the end of an era or just another fleur de lis footnote?
The post Derek Carr ‘Flirted’ With Multiple Teams Despite Raiders’ Forbiddance Before Retirement Decision- Report appeared first on EssentiallySports.
