The summers in the Bronx have witnessed some astonishing numbers. Credits? Their captain – Aaron Judge! One phenomenal performance at a time, he is writing a renowned narrative, not only playing baseball. The arena is filled with excitement when he steps up to the plate, where he shows his explosion of power and accuracy. Another MVP loading….
So far, this is a historic season for Aaron Judge, not only a good one. The sort of year that inspires discussions among all the MLB experts and drives arguments. The kind that makes you put down what you’re doing and listen. Compared to the game’s greats, the titans who previously graced these fields seem increasingly popular. Is he getting to that level? Is he etching his name into the stone of Yankee history next to Ruth, Berra, and DiMaggio?
Aaron Judge is topping the league in early May 2025 and marking his territory. His numbers are surely blowing our minds! A remarkable .427 batting average, 10 home runs, and 32 RBIs. His OPS, at an incredible 1.282, puts him in a league of the greats. Still not an all-time Yankee? A former high-ranking MLB executive, David Samson, shared his side on his podcast, raising eyebrows. “You can’t be an all-time Yankee without a World Series ring. Just stop that whole conversation. Get Aaron Judge one or two rings with three MVPs. You’re on that list.”
Surprising?
For Samson, Judge’s lack of a World Series ring is the clear setback. It’s the missing puzzle piece that keeps him from being mentioned alongside the Yankee legends who not only ruled personally but also guided their teams to October triumph. In the harsh terrain of New York sports, where titles are the highest currency, individual brilliance without team success can sometimes feel lacking.
Very smartly, he gave examples of the Yankee greats. “Three New York Yankees have won the MVP 3 times. Mickey Mantle, Yogi Berra, and Joe DiMaggio. How would you like to join the group of guys? Well, A-rod tried, but couldn’t win two MVPs with the Yankees. Roger Maris tried, couldn’t, won two MVPs with the Yankees.”
And Judge has won the MVP twice, first in 2022 and again in 2024. With 62 home runs, he broke the AL single-season home run record in 2022; he also had 131 RBIs, a .311 batting average, and a .425 on-base percentage. Equally remarkable was his 2024 season, which topped MLB with 58 home runs, 144 RBIs, and a .322 batting average. He also led the league in walks (133), on-base percentage (.458), slugging percentage (.701), and OPS (1.159), resulting in an 11.2 fWAR.
No wonder expectations for a 3rd time MVP are fueling! Look at his 2025 numbers.
Aaron Judge’s unprecedented 2025 performance
So far, this season is going smoothly for Judge. Aaron Judge became the first MLB player to hit five home runs and 15 RBIs in his team’s first six games. In his 1,000th career game, he matched Babe Ruth’s record of 321 home runs, demonstrating his power-hitting ability.
Judge has had 50 hits and 89 bases in April, a record before May. He led the league in walks with 70 in 30 days. His .761 slugging percentage demonstrates his offensive versatility. The eleventh American League talent of the Month honor came in April, cementing his standing as a top talent.
He has set the standard so high that even the second-best numbers look small. Pete Alonso of the New York Mets is 71 points behind at .342. That difference is not even close, and Judge ensures it stays that way.
Aaron Judge is poised to challenge many historic landmarks. He may finish with a .368 batting average, 62 home runs, and 158 RBIs. Joining Babe Ruth, Mark McGwire, and Sammy Sosa as a player with multiple 50-homer seasons could be a feat. He could also become the third MLB player behind Barry Bonds and Babe Ruth to hit at least 35 home runs in four seasons with a 170 wRC+.
There’s one more, though. Ichiro Suzuki established the MLB season hit record with 262 in 2004, a feat many assumed would never be challenged. But here we are. #99 might finish one hit short of that record. If he keeps up this pace, he could hit .400+, 50+ homers, and 260+ hits. That wouldn’t just be a terrific season—it could be the best offensive season baseball has ever seen.
Most players hit for average or power, not both. Judge, however, is revising the rules. Only a few MLB players have hit for average and power at this pace in 2025.
Now, all eyes are on what record he will break next! And can he finally lead the Bronx Bombers for the WS title! All eyes are on the upcoming games!
The post Despite Legendary Career, Aaron Judge Is Not in All-Time Yankee Conversation Claims Ex-MLB Exec in Bold Take appeared first on EssentiallySports.
