It was not supposed to look like this. Just a month and a half ago, the Giants doubled down on stability, keeping faith in their skipper by picking up his $4 million option. Back then, optimism ran high, with the aim of a deadline-fueled run still dancing in the minds of Giants fans. However, the reality has been far harsher, and the mood in the team has turned uneasy.
The collapse has been staggering. Since signing Rafael Devers and the $232 million deal from the Red Sox, the team has stumbled to an 18-31 record. The Giants’ freefall has included losing 14 of their last 15 games at Oracle Park—a meltdown unseen since 1901, back when Christy Mathewson was still a rookie. For a team that sold “win now” to its fans, the optics could not be worse.
Now comes the breaking point. As per USA TODAY Sports’ Bob Nightengale, the Giants are weighing a managerial change, possibly cutting ties with Bob Melvin despite having recently exercised his contract option. If the nosedive continues over the upcoming six weeks, the skipper could be gone, opening the door for former Marlins manager Skip Schumaker to become a prime candidate.
However, not everyone is ready to let that narrative stick. Matt Chapman, who has spent seven seasons under Melvin across two teams, has been unwavering in his defense of the veteran manager. “Everybody in here believes in the coaches, believes in Bob. No, it’s on the players,” Chapman admitted, pushing back against the flood of criticism. For the veteran, the liability rests squarely on the guys between the lines, not the man pulling the strings.
And Chapman’s loyalty runs deep. In fact, he said last season that he would not have signed his six-year, $151 million extension if Melvin were not part of the equation. “We win as a team. We lose as a team,” he said after yet another gut-punch loss to the Rays. It is a vital stand as social media chatter and radio debates continue to pin blame on Melvin. Yet the uncomfortable truth remains: in MLB, the dugout leader basically pays the cost when the gamble flops, no matter how loudly his stars back him.
While Chapman’s defense of the skipper highlights his loyalty, the irony is hard to miss—just as he is standing up for Melvin in the face of criticism, he is also dealing with his own battle off the field. Injuries have begun to pile up, forcing the team to confront another uncomfortable truth: the Giants’ most reliable cornerstones are not at full strength.
Injury woes add to the Giants’ mounting struggles
The largest gut punch came when Chapman, who has been grinding through pain since June, landed back on the injured list with lingering issues in the right hand. Chapman admitted swinging had become almost impossible recently, explaining how three tears in the hand left him battling soreness he could not shake. After receiving two cortisone shots, he sounded hopeful the setback could be brief; however, his .162 batting average in August tells the story of just how much the injury has affected his production.
Aug 20, 2024; San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants third base Matt Chapman (26) during the first inning against the Chicago White Sox at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports
If there was a sliver of good news, it came in the form of medical updates. X-rays came back negative for Chapman and another infielder, Casey Schmitt, sparing the team from a more devastating outcome. Still, the gap highlights the thin margin for error the Giants are living on. A lineup that was supposed to spark a second-half push has instead been riddled with frustration, and unless Chapman and Schmitt bounce back, the team’s uphill climb could get steeper by the day.
The Giants’ season has spiraled into a perfect storm of poor outcomes, mounting force, and untimely injuries. With Matt Chapman defending Bob Melvin, the whispers of transformation grow louder by the day.
`
The post Giants to Quietly Cut Ties With Manager Bob Melvin Despite Matt Chapman’s Objection – Report appeared first on EssentiallySports.
