It started like any other session on The Joe Rogan Experience: light teasing, a few mind games, and a guest who appeared more charming than frightening. Oz Pearlman, a mentalist with a knack for smooth talk, glided into the conversation like a party trick pro. But suddenly, without warning, it became personal. Not dramatic or loud—just a gradual shift in energy that clearly made Joe Rogan uncomfortable, particularly after his ATM PIN was guessed.
There’s a moment when you can sense that Rogan is becoming tense. That smile folks wear when they’re trying to keep their cool, but their eyes tell them otherwise. On JRE #2332, Pearlman had asked for a random four-digit number, and Rogan nonchalantly replied, “2020.” It seemed harmless—until it didn’t.
Oz Pearlman, calm and methodical, began breaking it down: how rushed decisions reveal trends and how males like to go large with their lies. It wasn’t flashy—just quietly unsettling. When he eventually scribbled something and handed it to Rogan off-camera, the host remained motionless.
“That’s weird,” he said, half to himself. Pearlman kept going and going. He joked, “You know he’s calling his bank right now,” but Rogan didn’t even chuckle. Just a simple “Yeah, I don’t like that.”
The tension increased when the UFC commentator, half-joking, asked, “Have you ever done that to people and then withdrawn money?” The magician grinned and replied, “No comment.” It didn’t land like a joke—it landed like a moment too real for comfort.
NEW: Joe Rogan clearly uncomfortable after ‘mentalist’ Oz Pearlman successfully guesses his ATM PIN code on his recent show.
Pearlman: How’d I do, Joe? Is that your ATM PIN code?
Rogan: Yeah… I don’t like that. pic.twitter.com/PH9MWtH9gU
— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) June 4, 2025
By the end, even Rogan seemed rattled. Was it a trick? Psychology? Or did someone actually guess his PIN code on air? Whatever it was, it went above the JRE host’s expectations. And judging by his nervous smile, it’s a clip that’s going to linger. However, it wasn’t the only moment that stunned the UFC commentator. To make things more interesting, he even got his future predicted on-air.
Joe Rogan gets stunned by a future prediction
If guessing an ATM PIN wasn’t enough to make Joe Rogan nervous, what happened next definitely did. Still clearly agitated, he attempted to reset the mood—shake it off and return to regular programming. But Oz Pearlman still had one card to play. A sealed envelope, which had been on the table since the beginning of the show, suddenly became the focus. “Let’s open it now,” Pearlman said with a relaxed grin. And with that, the tone changed again—this time to something disturbingly precise.
The envelope did not contain a fortune cookie line or a wild guess. It described a moment Rogan hadn’t shared out loud: “14 fighters will go through your head, and Anderson Silva will be the last.” It was an odd detail that somehow corresponded to what the JRE host had internally processed during the show.
You could see it in his expression—the way he blinked a little slowly, the smirk sliding into disbelief. “That’s insane,” he said, unsure of what to do with what had just happened. However, Pearlman did not believe it was magical. He dismissed the supernatural element and explained everything as part of his method—psychology, patterns, and timing.
But that didn’t make the experience any less weird. Even in a studio where Rogan has heard everything from alien hypotheses to quantum physics, this one stood out. What do you think? How did the mentalist pull it off? Let us know in the comments.
The post Joe Rogan Left Uncomfortable as Personal Life Details Get Leaked by Mentalist JRE Guest appeared first on EssentiallySports.
