Some debates are timeless—like “Is water wet?” or “Was The Godfather Part III necessary?” But baseball just lobbed us another: A certain modern-day superstar daring to rank himself above a certain backward-cap-wearing legend. Enter Mike Trout and Ken Griffey Jr., the spark behind MLB’s latest fan frenzy. Turns out, when you tinker with royalty in cleats, you’d better be ready to duck.
One of the hardest things to do in baseball is to create a team that has some of the best players. And the only thing harder than that is to convince the people why they get in before the other person. That is exactly what happened when The Athletic tried to create the best MLB team with players from the past 25 years.
Not Gaetti’s X handle took this line up and added some of his opinion. “Can you think of anyone you’d replace on @jaysonst’s MLB All-Quarter-Century Team? (If you say Ohtani over Ortiz, my answer is maybe [probably?] at some point, but not yet.) For me, the lowest-hanging fruit is Molina, but is anyone actually a lock to replace him? I’m not sure.”
They had Yadier Molina as the catcher, Aaron Judge in the right field, and David Ortiz as the DH, but one thing caught the eye of some MLB fans, and they are not happy. The center field had Mike Trout, but people expected another baller – Ken Griffey Jr.
Can you think of anyone you’d replace on @jaysonst’s MLB All-Quarter-Century Team?
(If you say Ohtani over Ortiz, my answer is maybe [probably?] at some point, but not yet.)
For me, the lowest-hanging fruit is Molina, but is anyone actually a lock to replace him? I’m not sure. pic.twitter.com/bDLv6iodam
— Not Gaetti (@notgaetti) May 22, 2025
The debate over Mike Trout‘s placement over Ken Griffey Jr. in The Athletic’s All-Quarter Century Team has ignited passionate discussions among MLB fans. While Trout’s early career was marked by exceptional performance, recent years have seen a decline due to injuries. Since 2019, Trout has played in only 51% of the Angels’ games, mirroring the injury-plagued later years of Griffey Jr.’s career.
Despite these setbacks, Trout’s achievements remain significant. He boasts a .297 batting average, 387 home runs, and 972 RBIs as of April 2025. However, the comparison to Griffey Jr., who ended his career with 630 home runs and 10 Gold Glove Awards, continues to fuel the debate. Fans are left pondering whether Trout’s early dominance outweighs Griffey Jr.’s sustained excellence and iconic status.
So, is it better to burn bright and fast or to shine steadily for decades? When comparing Trout and Griffey Jr., it’s less about stats and more about soul. Trout may have the numbers, but Griffey had the narrative—and the Nike ads. In the end, history isn’t just written in box scores, it’s etched in baseball hearts (and posters on bedroom walls).
The MLB world raises eyebrows over the snub of Ken Griffey Jr. at center
Some choices are meant to unite—others, to launch a thousand think pieces and social media wars. When it comes to naming all-time greats, baseball fans don’t just disagree—they form opposing nations. That’s exactly what happened when Mike Trout was crowned over Ken Griffey Jr. in a recent lineup. Because in MLB lore, snubbing “The Kid” is like replacing hot dogs at the ballpark with tofu wraps.
Is Ken Griffey not eligible? And ARod?
— 1970s Baseball (@70sBaseball) May 22, 2025
This feels less like a question and more like an outcry. Griffey wasn’t just eligible—he was the poster child for greatness with 630 homers. Leaving him out is like skipping The Beatles on a ’60s playlist—unthinkable. The man won 10 Gold Gloves while hitting bombs with a smile and a backward cap.
I’m not a Mike Trout Guy. So Griffey Jr for his brief stint or Beltran.
I’m also not a failed test guy, which is why Jeter over A- Fraud.
U could argue Joe Mauer or Buster Posey, but I’ll take the defense in Molina. Pretty hard to argue the others.
Gimme Roger Clemens over…
— Rubble (@RobStep20437670) May 22, 2025
“I’m not a Mike Trout guy, So Griffey Jr for his brief stint or Beltran.” And honestly, Ken Griffey Jr. gives you every reason not to be. Griffey smashed 56 homers in back-to-back seasons, while making highlight-reel catches look casual. His “brief stint” still produced an MVP, 13 All-Star nods, and iconic baseball moments. That sweet swing alone could justify a statue, let alone a spot on this elite team.
“Mike Sellout Trout—No thanks.” Some fans see Trout as more commercial than clutch. But behind the brand, he’s a 9-time All-Star and three-time MVP. His consistent excellence and impact redefine greatness, whether critics like it or not. Love him or hate him, Trout’s stats demand respect on any All-Quarter Century Team.
“Have to put Griffey in, is a quarter-century during a certain timeline?” Griffey’s prime defined the ’90s and early 2000s. His 10 consecutive Gold Gloves set defensive standards few can match. Even if the timeline’s tight, his impact reshaped center field and inspired a generation of players.
“Griffey Jr has to be on it. Bounce Judge.” Griffey’s smooth swing and iconic highlight reels outshine any rookie hype. His Hall of Fame aura and lasting influence beat Judge’s recent bursts. Longevity and style? Griffey owns them, making a stronger case for the quarter-century team spot.
It is evident that when baseball legends clash, fans don’t just debate—they declare wars of loyalty and stats. Mike Trout’s brilliance is undeniable, but Ken Griffey Jr.’s legendary charisma and lasting influence cast a long shadow. Choosing between them isn’t just picking players—it’s picking eras, styles, and fan passions. The real winner in the end? The endless, entertaining debate itself. Because in MLB, the only thing certain is that the arguments never retire.
The post Mike Trout’s Center Field Preference Over Ken Griffey Jr Triggers Backlash From MLB Fans appeared first on EssentiallySports.
