Shedeur Sanders, the human highlight reel who rewrote Colorado’s record books (4,134 pass yds, 37 TDs, 74% comp in 2024), isn’t just fighting for draft position. He’s battling perception. Critics call him a “system QB” coddled by his dad’s swagger-soaked aura. Supporters point to that 510-yard bombshell against TCU in 2023. A game so electric it made SportsCenter’s Top 10 look like a PowerPoint. But as Tony Soprano once growled, ‘Remember the good times.’ For Shedeur, the ‘good times’ might hinge on whether Big Blue sees magic in his tape… or just a mirage.
“I’m hearing that he isn’t a great athlete on tape, doesn’t have exceptional arm talent. And too often does things that simply won’t translate to the NFL game.” When NFL insider Albert Breer dropped this grenade about Sanders’s draft stock, it hit harder than a blindside sack. But here’s the twist. While scouts debate whether Coach Prime’s son is a first-round flier or a Day 2 project, the New York Giants just booked a private jet to Boulder, Colorado, for a last-minute workout with the Buffs’ QB1. Talk about mixed signals.
Wild: There aren’t many coaches or scouts who view Shedeur Sanders as a first-round talent, per @AlbertBreer
“I’m hearing that he isn’t a great athlete on tape, doesn’t have exceptional arm talent, and too often does things that simply won’t translate to the NFL game.”… pic.twitter.com/1cHSGvUikG
— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) April 15, 2025
Let’s be real: Shedeur Sanders isn’t your average prospect. The kid’s rocking a $6.5M NIL empire — Nike deals, Beats collabs, even BBQ sauce — making his dad Deion’s rookie contract look like pocket change. But NFL GMs aren’t drafting marketability; they’re drafting arm talent.
And Breer’s critique cuts deep: “Doesn’t have exceptional arm talent.” Oof. Yet, Giants GM Joe Schoen sees something. Maybe it’s Shedeur’s 2024 stats (No. 3 in FBS QBR) or his “I’m the most guaranteed risk you take” bravado during the Shrine Bowl. Or maybe it’s the ghost of Eli Manning haunting MetLife, begging for a successor.
Enter the Giants’ dilemma: They’re sitting at No. 3 with a 3-14 hangover and a QB room of rehab projects (Russ Wilson, Jameis Winston). Shedeur’s workout isn’t just a formality — it’s a vibe check. Can he thrive outside Coach Prime’s VIP booth? Does his Madden obsession with the Browns’ playbook (“I like how they move around on there”) translate to Daboll’s scheme? And hey, why’s he tweeting “Thank you, GOD” after every Raiders loss? NYC doesn’t do subtle, kid.
Giants’ gamble: Sanders savior or smoke screen?
Here’s the poetic part: The Giants, a franchise built on LT’s menace and Eli’s ice veins, are now betting on a QB who’s equal parts influencer and underdog. Shedeur’s not just selling jerseys — he’s selling hope. His NIL empire proves he’s a CEO in cleats, but GM Schoen needs a play-caller, not a pitchman. Meanwhile, Big Blue’s $44.3M cap space and No. 3 pick scream, “NOW OR NEVER.”
But let’s not romanticize this. Shedeur’s 2024 tape has holes: Happy feet under pressure, forced throws into double coverage, and a 10-INT regression that’s red-flag city. Still, his swagger’s infectious. When he unboxed those Raiders-themed Nikes with “Thank you GOD” scribbled inside, it wasn’t just drip — it was defiance. NYC eats that for breakfast.
As the draft looms, Shedeur’s story feels ripped from Friday Night Lights (oops, scratch that — no FNL references). The Giants’ private workout isn’t just a scouting session — it’s a litmus test for legacy. Will Shedeur be the next Manning or the next Malik Willis?
One thing’s certain: Whether he’s slinging dots in East Rutherford or riding pine in Cleveland, Shedeur Sanders has already won. Because in the NIL era, even “bad news” can’t dim a $6.5M spotlight.
The post National Reporter Confirms Bad News for Shedeur Sanders as NY Giants Hold Private Workout With Colorado QB appeared first on EssentiallySports.
