Not that long ago, everything looked golden. Back in June, the Mets sat at 45-24, carrying the best record in MLB and backed by a rotation that looked untouchable. A sparkling 2.79 ERA and a quartet of stars delivering consistency had fans thinking the management’s vision was finally paying off. For a while, the formula was working.
However, as quickly as hope arrived, the unraveling began. Since that high point, the Mets have stumbled to a 20-34 record, with only the Nationals faring worse in that stretch. The once-mighty team has become a liability, throwing the fewest innings in MLB and coughing up a bloated 5.35 ERA. What was once the Mets’ biggest power has now become its largest burden, and the timing could not be worse.
This is where the deadline decisions come back into sharp focus. Instead of securing a proven starter, the team chose to double down on their bullpen, adding Ryan Helsley, Tyler Rogers, and Brooks Raley. For some, it looked like a vital move. In practice, the trio surrendered six runs in just 1⅔ innings on Friday and blew yet another lead. It marked the seventh straight game the Mets let one slip away late, losing six of those. That is not just bad luck — that is structural failures.
Naturally, the big concern becomes: who shoulders the blame? David Stearns’ deadline approach earned an “A” grade at the time; however, hindsight paints a harsher picture. Betting on reinforcements from the minors — Nolan McLean, Brandon Sproat, and Jonah Tong — was always risky.
And so, the narrative transforms. A management lauded for patience and smart maneuvering is now under fire for losing a golden opportunity. The “A” at the deadline has become an “F” in the midterm grades, a collapse of the Mets that speaks volumes related to how fragile contender status can be. For the Mets, the harsh reality is simple: the gamble did not pay off, and now, every missed win looks like a haunting reminder of what could have been.
Credit: Imago
However, in such a situation, baseball has a funny way of providing a silver lining. Just when the team needed something to believe in, a 24-year-old rookie came forward onto the field and gave them — and their fans — a glimpse of hope for the future.
Mets rookie Nolan McLean provides a rare spark amid ongoing collapses.
On Saturday, the Mets got exactly what the team had been missing for weeks: a starter who looked fearless and in command. Nolan McLean, making his much-anticipated debut, delivered 5 ⅓ scoreless innings against the Mariners, where he struck out eight and earned a standing ovation from more than 42,000 fans at Citi Field. The star’s five-pitch mix — highlighted by a curveball in the 70s, a sweeper in the high 80s, and a fastball pushing the upper 90s — had the Mariners hitters off balance all night. For the team desperate for reliable stars, McLean’s outing was not just elite, it was desperately needed.
However, what stood out was not just the numbers — it was the composure. In the third inning, with the bases loaded and Julio Rodríguez at the plate, Nolan McLean turned a powerful disaster into a highlight-reel play. The star’s no-look and behind-the-back grab sparked a 1-4-3 double play, and it sent the fans into a frenzy. “I think that play was majority luck, honestly,” he joked after the game; however, for the Mets, it was like fate handing the team a lifeline. As Francisco Lindor put it: “The more the crowd got involved, the more he fed off it.” For the team in freefall, such energy is priceless.
New York Introduces David Stearns as New York Mets President Of Baseball Operations. David Stearns addresses the media at a press conference, PK, Pressekonferenz at Citi Field in Corona, New York, Monday, Oct. 2, 2023. New York, United States PUBLICATIONxNOTxINxFRA Copyright: xGordonxDonovanx originalFilename:donovan-newyorkm231002_npN1v.jpg
The Mets entered the deadline hoping to flip the script; however, the outcome so far has provided more frustration than relief. Instead of a boost, the team has been handed a reality check that highlights the widening gap between their intentions and their execution. With October hopes dimming, the concern now becomes whether David Stearns’ cautious gamble can still pay off.
`
The post New York Mets Handed Bitter Reality Check as David Stearns’ Trade Deadline Moves Suffer Blunt Blow Amid Collapse appeared first on EssentiallySports.
