The Yankees find themselves in the thick of an AL East tussle, and it is getting uglier with each passing day. Once comfortably atop the division, they have now been caught by the surging Blue Jays, and as David Samson put it bluntly, “You can feel the heat in New York. And I’m not talking just temperature.” The tension is not just about the standings. It is about decisions or indecisions that are costing the Yankees in critical moments, and those calls are coming from the dugout.
Just one single decision raised eyebrows across the league involving Jazz Chisholm Jr. Acquired with hopes of providing a spark and flexibility, the 26-year-old started at second base, his natural and most effective position. But after DJ LeMahieu’s comeback and Oswaldo Peraza’s injury, the Yankees shifted Chisholm to third. On the surface, it seemed like a stopgap move. But in reality, it has become a long-term misfit. “They’re playing Jazz in a position he shouldn’t be in,” Samson noted. And the cost? Defensive inconsistency and a star player being overwhelmed.
Transitioning from that, the frustrating part is that Chisholm has not complained; he has shown up, played hard, and adapted. Samson called him a “state trooper” for his effort, but even loyalty has certain limits. Aaron Boone’s response when asked if Chisholm might return to second? “We’ll talk through that stuff.” That is not exactly confidence-inspiring. Particularly when LeMahieu, currently equipping second, is struggling both at the plate and on the field. The defensive downfall is evident, and it has started to drag the team down in high-leverage moments.
However, the larger concern looms: Who is truly responsible in this situation? Is it Boone, who looks hesitant to act decisively, or Brian Cashman, whose roster construction has left little flexibility? Either way, as David Samson highlighted, ownership could have to make a tough call—quickly. “Something has to happen in New York,” Samson warned, highlighting the possibility of a shake-up. The fans are not blind, and they see a winning roster playing musical chairs while the division tightens. If the team continues to underwhelm, the interaction around Chisholm’s place will be the least of their concerns. It could become a full-blown reckoning.
However, beyond positional juggling and managerial indecision, there is another core issue bubbling beneath the surface — one that star performances can not patch forever. This brings us to the captain’s candid assessment of the team’s downward spiral.
Aaron Judge breaks silence as Yankees core cracks under pressure
When the team’s captain finally steps up to address the chaos, you know the force is getting real. Aaron Judge, who rarely makes excuses and points fingers, did not sugarcoat it—the captain admitted the Yankees simply are not getting it done. “We got to play better,” Judge said after their 13th loss in 19 games. The star also focused on accountability, steering attention inward instead of blaming standings and rivals. It is a tone the team needed to hear. However, it also speaks volumes: the Yankees’ issues are not outer—they are internal.
Still, the irony is hard to ignore. Judge, despite his sudden slump, is putting up historic stats. He leads the league in virtually every major offensive category and already has 31 home runs. Yet, even that brilliance can not protect a bullpen plagued by defensive lapses and clutch-hitting woes. In this recent stretch, Judge has dipped slightly, hitting .254, but even that comes with a .987 OPS. The issue? The rest of the lineup is not pulling its weight. As the captain shines alone, the Yankees are learning the hard way: no team survives with one single athlete carrying the whole weight of the crown.
The Yankees find themselves at a crossroads, with mounting pressure from fans, media, and even within their own clubhouse. Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s positional shuffle and Aaron Judge’s pointed honesty are just symptoms of deeper problems. If changes are not made soon, whether in the lineup or leadership, the AL East crown might drop away for good. Stay tuned.
`
The post New York MLB Owners Asked To Make Tough Managerial Call after Yankees Push Jazz Chisholm Jr. Into Unfamiliar Role appeared first on EssentiallySports.
