Loyalty in baseball is often marketed as eternal, but in Queens, it carries an expiration date. Pete Alonso keeps rewriting the Mets’ record book, yet the applause feels awkwardly timed against Carlos Mendoza’s public scolding. When a slugger delivers and a manager points fingers, the scoreboard tells only half the truth. What remains is a stage where patience is dwindling and future allegiances suddenly look negotiable.
If you thought that the New York Mets were a close-knit family, you were right, until now. Because things have stopped going their way, frustration is starting to set in, and fingers are starting to point at each other. And amid all this, Pete Alonso’s loyalty to the Mets is being tested, and guess what, it might not be as strong as imagined.
In a recent show on SNY, they talked about Pete Alonso and the rumors of him not wanting to renew with the Mets. They said, “Uh, yes to all of those questions. Yeah, I think barring a serious injury, uh Pete Alonso is going to opt out… The contract was designed for him to opt out. Unless he had a a got hurt or had a really bad season, he was going to opt out from the start of the year.”
Pete Alonso has thrived for the Mets in 2025, hitting 28 homers with 96 RBIs in 119 games. His batting average stands around .268, OPS is approximately .871, showcasing a powerhouse all-star offensive profile. Alonso broke Darryl Strawberry’s decades-old franchise home run record in August amid a heartfelt pregame ceremony. His consistency and improving performance affirm that his short-term deal has already delivered exceptional returns for New York.
Image: MLB.com
Meanwhile, Mets manager Carlos Mendoza openly criticized his rotation’s inconsistency and mounting bullpen strain this summer amid organizational frustration. His pointed comments about starters burning through innings quickly and igniting relief misuse underscore locker-room instability and internal pressures. Such leadership honesty, though warranted, may signal to Alonso that his team remains structurally fragile behind him, raising concerns. Those same concerns could strengthen his motivation to opt out and find a more stable, long-term arrangement elsewhere.
Alonso’s extraordinary season—leading to franchise lore—makes opting out increasingly tempting as he bets on himself. Analysts expect him to leverage his rebound campaign for a multi-year contract worth well over $100 million at free agency. The symbolic timing of Mendoza’s public critiques during a pivotal season adds emotional weight to Alonso’s decision calculus. Those cracks, visible now amid the pressure, may just be the push Alonso needs toward free agency certainty.
In the end, Pete Alonso’s bat is delivering while Carlos Mendoza’s words are dividing. The Mets may call themselves a family, but families that bicker in public rarely keep their stars. Alonso was always likely to opt out, yet Mendoza’s finger-pointing makes the exit door look brighter. And if the Mets can’t stop tripping over their shoelaces, Alonso’s loyalty won’t just fade — it’ll sprint away.
If rumors are true, Pete Alonso might just pull a Bronx move.
Baseball loyalty often looks permanent until the contract fine print says otherwise. The Mets thought they were buying time with Pete Alonso, but time runs faster when the Yankees are lurking across town. Alonso keeps crushing home runs while New York’s orange-and-blue brass debates his future, and the irony is rich: the franchise that once hesitated to pay him might watch him cash in with their pinstriped rivals.
Pete Alonso is locked in a two-year, $54 million Mets deal with a 2026 opt-out clause. The agreement guarantees $30 million for 2025 and affords both flexibility and an elite annual salary. Though the Mets retain their franchise home-run king, Alonso’s openness to free agency looms next winter. His short-term pact cleverly balances the Mets’ control versus Alonso’s future opportunity.
Whispers suggest Alonso’s shared Florida and University of Florida ties with Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner intensify inter-borough speculation. That personal link might give the Yankees an unexpected edge when Alonso hits free agency. Adding a durable power bat like Alonso could reinvigorate New York’s lineup and clubhouse leadership. For the Yanks, landing Alonso would fuse crosstown marketing appeal with a powerful offensive upgrade.
In the end, the Mets’ two-year gamble with Pete Alonso may feel like rented time rather than long-term security. Because if Hal Steinbrenner’s Yankees decide to flex both their wallet and their Florida connection, the Mets’ restraint could become their rival’s jackpot. Alonso’s bat doesn’t just hit baseballs—it hits bottom lines, attendance charts, and October dreams. And if loyalty expires at the fine print, Queens may soon watch its hero cross the Harlem River in pinstripes.
The post Pete Alonso’s Mets Loyalty to Fade Away as Carlos Mendoza Points Fingers at Own Clubhouse appeared first on EssentiallySports.
