What happens when your head coach experiments, then publicly admits, “I don’t plan on doing it again”? That’s what Sean McDermott just served up to Bills fans, tossing a preseason idea out the window after a single Saturday test drive against the Giants. And with MVP quarterback Josh Allen on the sideline and sporting a whole new look, the aftershocks in Buffalo just keep coming.
If you were locked into that Week 1 preseason opener, you knew this wasn’t your typical Bills lineup. McDermott held out Allen and a handful of starters for caution’s sake, including running back James Cook, who’s deep in contract talks and using a “hold-in” strategy. Cook’s absence was part of an ongoing contract “hold-in” that the team and media have been covering during training camp. But in the chaos, Allen made noise off the field, his footwear switch from Nike to head-to-toe New Balance gear sent sneakerheads scrambling. The message? Change is coming, and not just on the scoreboard.
Then came McDermott’s curious sideline call. When Ray Davis lined up to kick, it was a preseason pit stop that left everyone buzzing: could Buffalo count on emergency kicks from skill players down the stretch? McDermott offered no illusions about making a habit out of it, saying, “I don’t want him to pull a hamstring, whatever, trying to kick an extra point or a field goal… I don’t plan on doing it again. I think once is enough. It was good for us to do it, but we need a real plan if Ray scores, maybe a pit stop, somebody else.” The reaction in Orchard Park was swift, fun idea, coach, but let’s stick to what works on Sundays.
Here’s where the story really turns. While Allen didn’t take a snap, his off-field moves were even louder than the missing touchdown tosses. Sporting unreleased New Balance cleats and apparel, Allen’s quiet exit from Nike all but confirmed a new footwear endorsement is inbound. Allen was seen wearing New Balance cleats and apparel at minicamp and the preseason; New Balance has not yet announced an official partnership. Bills insiders say there’s no official announcement yet, but Allen rolling into Highmark Stadium in New Balance threads signals more than a fashion preference, it’s a likely brand deal on the horizon, just as younger QBs like Caleb Williams follow in his sneaker steps.
Buffalo loves Josh Allen.
1PM ET on @NFLNetwork
Stream on @NFLPlus pic.twitter.com/kMuvw9D0zk
— NFL (@NFL) August 9, 2025
McDermott, meanwhile, dealt with more than lineup experiments. His late-half and fourth-down decisions were dissected in real time, with some calling out “Mr. Conservative” for kicking when fans wanted him to go for six. As senior columnist Chuck Pollock noted, “That’s the kind of thinking which reveals why the Bills haven’t made the Super Bowl during McDermott’s tenure.” Every snap, every sideline call nothing goes uncriticized in Buffalo.
The ripple effects of Josh Allen’s contract on Buffalo’s cap space and evolving culture
Allen’s headline-grabbing, record $330 million extension, with $250 million guaranteed, just put him in rarified NFL air. But there’s more to the deal than eye-popping digits; Allen was quick to frame his negotiation mindset for fans: “I wasn’t looking to absolutely kill [the Bills] at every chance I could… If it has any impact on the cap, let’s figure out a way to not do that.” With his cap hit actually decreasing for next season, GM Brandon Beane praised Allen for his “team-first mindset” in keeping Buffalo competitive.
The real question for Bills Nation: where does the franchise go with its MVP QB locked in for 6 more years, a coach openly tweaking game plans mid-preseason, and new stars like James Cook using contract leverage to sit but not hold out? Allen’s off-field shift to New Balance might just mirror a changing organizational culture: new deals, new risks, and new ways to win.
Yet as Buffalo aims for AFC supremacy, there’s a sense of urgency for McDermott to tighten up game management and get more daring when it counts. Allen told reporters, “I live a pretty good life. Got a house, got a car. We’re good.” But he also insisted his new deal wasn’t just about money, it was about flexibility and championship pursuit. That mindset, more than any offseason branding, might just be the secret formula.
DETROIT, MI – DECEMBER 15: Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen 17 talks to the fans during the Detroit Lions versus the Buffalo Bills game on Sunday December 15, 2024 at Ford Field in Detroit, MI. Photo by Steven King/Icon Sportswire NFL, American Football Herren, USA DEC 15 Bills at Lions EDITORIAL USE ONLY Icon258202412150668
If one preseason experiment can reveal a coach’s willingness to adapt, could it also forecast greater changes ahead? For fans, it’s an open-ended playbook. What’s the next surprise coming to Buffalo’s gridiron? Will McDermott’s quick pivots finally pay off, or will Allen’s fresh endorsement mark the start of something bigger on and off the field? With the regular season looming, the only guarantee is that every move in Buffalo will be under the microscope.
The post Sean McDermott Abandons Plan After 1 Game as Josh Allen Teases New Deal Outside Bills appeared first on EssentiallySports.
