Wearing the pinstripes means carrying the legacy of giants. Every swing, every pitch, and every game bears the burden of 27 titles. And for Aaron Judge, it’s been no exception. He might have won two MVPS, but a significant milestone is yet to be achieved. A milestone that will open the gates to enter the room of Yankees forever.
So far this season, some firecrackers have been seen from Aaron Judge’s bat. How far did it go? Far enough, even NFL legends are talking about it. But despite a stunning .427 batting average, 10 home runs, and 32 RBIs, he is lagging. Even after putting up such good numbers?
Well, in a candid conversation on WFAN radio on May 2, 2025, NFL legend Tiki Barber had a take. He said, “For Judge to be an elite Yankee, he’s got to keep doing what he’s doing. Maybe one more MVP, but most importantly, he has to win a championship.” Yes, the missing piece of the puzzle is the World Championship ring.
On @EvanandTikiWFAN, @ShaunMorash, @TikiBarber and @EvanRobertsWFAN debated whether Aaron Judge or Jalen Brunson should be crowned the current “King of New York” pic.twitter.com/u6xdVNRFdZ
— SNY (@SNYtv) May 2, 2025
Leading the league in this era is not easy, and coming on the same list as Ruth and Bonds is not easy. But his on-base percentage is a remarkable .521, and his OPS climbs to 1.282. Such dominance puts him in exceptional company; only Barry Bonds and Babe Ruth have accomplished comparable accomplishments over a 162-game period. Judge’s unyielding quest for perfection is not only about personal honors; it reflects his dedication to the team’s success.
It’s not the first time Aaron Judge has faced criticism despite an excellent performance. Just a few days back, an MLB executive, David Samson, somewhat echoed the exact words. He said, “You can’t be an all-time Yankee without a World Series ring. Just stop that whole conversation. Get Aaron Judge one or two rings with three MVPs. You’re on that list.”
Aaron Judge is spinning a story written with ability, commitment, and an unrelenting quest for excellence in baseball’s vast fabric. Although his accomplishments are impressive, the title still stands as the crowning jewel, the last component in his drive to be remembered among the Yankees’ legends.
Even his performance is in question, and the experts continue to debate. The underlying story in New York still focuses on whether this degree of personal greatness can result in earning another MVP.
Judge reigns supreme in early MVP race
The Bronx captain is the talk of the town. Apart from his championship feat, he is all set to name another MVP in his name. Wondering with whom he is competing? The LA Dodgers star, Shohei Ohtani.
Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani, two game giants, are once more setting themselves apart from the rest of the league as the 2025 MLB season develops. Reigning MVPs in their respective leagues, both players have started the season with performances that satisfy and go beyond the high standards established by their prior successes.
The captain of the New York Yankees, Aaron Judge, has been nothing short of amazing. Ending April, he had an astonishing .427 batting average, supported by a .521 on-base percentage and a .761 slugging percentage, achieving an OPS of 1.282. And how can we forget his 10 homers? Such numbers emphasize his supremacy at the plate and his crucial part in the Yankees’ offensive lineup.
Across the nation, Shohei Ohtani of the Los Angeles Dodgers had a slow start, but he is back in action. Ohtani’s offensive contributions are still significant even if he is not pitching and has recovered from elbow surgery. He has a batting average of .264, an on-base percentage of .366, and a slugging percentage of .506, along with six home runs and five stolen bases. Although these figures are good, they put him behind Judge in the early MVP talks.
MLB expert Jared Carrabis was clear on the MVP scene: “There is a significant gap in the American League MVP race. In my short list of two, there is only one who is within striking distance of the leader, and that leader is Aaron Judge.”
Both individuals will undoubtedly be at the center of their teams’ pursuit of victory as the season goes on. Their performances not only improve their teams but also enhance the fabric of baseball with stories of excellence, tenacity, and the unyielding quest for greatness.
Although a possible third MVP award would confirm his brilliance even more. But the focus will be more on Judge’s ability to guide the Yankees to their 28th World Series championship.
The post Unswayed by Babe Ruth Comparisons, NFL Legend Tells Aaron Judge Why He’s Not a Yankees Great appeared first on EssentiallySports.
