In the Bronx, sentimentality doesn’t slug .300—performance does. The New York Yankees, never shy about pruning even their most decorated branches, have once again reminded fans and veterans alike that the pinstripes come with pressure. DJ LeMahieu, once a lineup lock, now finds himself on the outside looking in. And as always, opinions are flying faster than a Judge moonshot in July.
DJ LeMahieu getting DFA’d has become one of the biggest news stories for the past couple of days. But is anybody surprised? The New York Yankees are going through a rough patch, and they will need all their players to bring their A Game. And in the current situation, LeMahieu was nowhere near coming into form. Now, after his release, ex-MLB star A.J. Pierzynski shared that he backs the Yankees for making this move.
In his recent appearance on Foul Territory, he talked about why DJ LeMahieu’s release was the right choice. “At the end of the day, no, he doesn’t have a case because they’re trying to win… They need every hand, all hands on deck right now, and if he can’t play third and he can’t do things they need him to do, then the Yankees have no other choice.”
The Yankees’ decision to designate DJ LeMahieu for assignment sent tremors through the clubhouse. Once a cornerstone infielder, LeMahieu found himself physically limited and statistically underwhelming. He hit just .266 with two home runs and 12 RBIs across 45 games. Defensively, he couldn’t handle third base duties, forcing Aaron Boone’s hand in a crowded infield.
LeMahieu, understandably upset, did not request a release but made his displeasure subtly clear. “There were lengthy discussions… LeMahieu didn’t ask for his release and is not happy with the outcome,” Bryan Hoch reported. Boone added, “He was willing to begin working at 3B again, but it was too demanding.” It’s a tough fall for a three-time All-Star and four-time Gold Glove winner.
DJ LeMahieu doesn’t have a case to be upset about getting released, says @AJPierzynski12.
“If he can’t play third and can’t do things they need him to do, then the Yankees have no other choice.” pic.twitter.com/kj7b0vL3jB
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) July 10, 2025
From the Yankees’ view, this was a cold but necessary business move ahead of the deadline. LeMahieu’s $22 million contract through 2026 became an expensive seat on the bench. Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s shift to second and Oswald Peraza’s emergence at third sealed his fate. The infield puzzle had no space left for a declining veteran with physical limitations.
However, the fallout does leave the Yankees thin in utility depth, relying solely on Jorbit Vivas. Still, they gain roster flexibility and could pursue a younger, more dynamic third-base option. The move signals a clear message: Sentiment won’t block competitiveness in the Bronx. For LeMahieu, a minor-league deal or buyout may be the only doors left ajar.
In a clubhouse where nostalgia doesn’t win pennants, tough calls become necessary currency. DJ LeMahieu‘s exit, though jarring, fits the Yankees’ ruthless pursuit of relevance. The message is crystal clear: If you can’t field, hit, or hustle, pinstripes won’t protect you.
The Yankees look to go all in to improve the team
The New York Yankees don’t blink when it’s time to swing the axe, especially not with October on the line. In a clubhouse where sentiment takes a backseat to stats, DJ LeMahieu just learned the hard way that past All-Star nods don’t buy future innings. His DFA wasn’t just a roster move—it was a warning shot. The Bronx is no place for nostalgia when a title chase is burning.
Designating DJ LeMahieu for assignment wasn’t just subtraction—it was strategic addition in disguise. The Yankees cleared a roster spot with purpose, eyeing a potential high-impact acquisition before the trade deadline. With LeMahieu no longer dependable at second or third base, the team couldn’t justify keeping him idle. This move screams urgency as the Yankees scramble to stay afloat in the AL East race.
General manager Brian Cashman didn’t mince words when discussing the DFA fallout. “I’m always interested in adding something that’ll have a big impact, that’ll supercharge us,” he said, per Max Goodman. Cashman emphasized the Yankees are “going to go to town” to improve the team. His wishlist includes starting pitching, bullpen help, and infield reinforcements.
The trade deadline now looms like a pressure cooker set to explode in the Bronx. Cashman added, “We’re going to do everything we possibly can to improve ourselves… and take our shot.” Sentiment is shelved, ambition is prioritized, and no move is too bold. The Yankees aren’t just buying—they’re betting big on a World Series-or-bust mission.
In the Bronx, loyalty ends where losing begins—and DJ LeMahieu just found the line. The Yankees have cracked open their war chest, and Brian Cashman’s looking less like a GM and more like a poker player on tilt. With a bloated roster trimmed and trade season heating up, no move is off the table. Titles aren’t handed out for tenure. In New York, they’re bought with guts, grit, and gutsier trades.
The post Yankees’ DJ LeMahieu DFA Call Draws Strong Support as Ex-MLB Star Criticizes Reaction to Reduced Role appeared first on EssentiallySports.
