The city that never sleeps is divided into two boroughs with an eternal grudge. When it comes to the towering facades of the Bronx and the bustling streets of Queens, baseball becomes something beyond just a game. On top of that, Juan Soto’s decision has not only created chaos but also confusion about why he chose the Mets over the Yankees. And this Yankee legend claims to know precisely why.
Juan Soto’s Mets orange and blue ensemble astonished baseball fans in a city where loyalties are as deeply rooted as subway lines. While Queens supporters rejoiced at a franchise turning point, Bronx faithful were disappointed and skeptical. Some of them still wonder why he chose to go on the other side? The lavish contract? Or was it something else?
Interestingly, Soto’s choice did not surprise everyone. Former Yankees and Mets pitcher David Cone offered his thoughts during a recent visit on Amazin‘ Conversations with Jay Horwitz. He said, “To tell you the truth, Jay, I wasn’t surprised at all.” He has been a part of the Queens, and from his experience, he knows. “Because of going back to the Old Timers Day… with the Mets, that I got a chance to meet the ownership. I got to meet Mr. and Mrs. Cohen. And I saw first-hand how dynamic they are, how warm they are. Particularly how interested they were to hang out in the clubhouse and meet guys, and how approachable they were.”
.@dcone36 wasn’t shocked at all when @JuanSoto25_ jumped from the Yankees to the @Mets last winter. He credits the move to the family atmosphere that Alex and Steve Cohen have created in Queens.
https://t.co/Qnf8rZ6gnm
https://t.co/3J3waFuk2p pic.twitter.com/kjuKYSepeY
— Jay Horwitz (@Jay_HorwitzPR) May 14, 2025
Cone’s insights are valuable due to his impressive career and strong familiarity with the Yankees and Mets. He has witnessed their ownership styles, clubhouse relationships, and inner workings. So, when the trade news broke out, he knew all the answers to those questions.
“So I knew right away… I wasn’t surprised. I could see them selling Juan Soto and his family on a family atmosphere with the Mets. And that’s what’s going on in Queens right now. That’s the dynamic.” “I can absolutely understand why Juan Soto and his family picked the Mets.”
With the Subway series coming (May 16 to 18), the pressure and excitement can be easily sensed. But Juan Soto is very relaxed, and it makes everyone wonder, how? In a recent interview, he said, “I think the Subway Series is just another series where we have to go out there and try to win. “We have to keep moving forward, forget about who we’re going to face, and just try to win the series because, in the end, that’s what we’re here for.”
As the opening pitch of this highly anticipated Subway Series creeps nearer, the spotlight will definitely be on Soto’s first clash with his previous team. That will tell whether it’s truly just another series or not.
The Subway Series: A new chapter in a historic rivalry
Apart from Soto’s comeback, the Subway Series presents a vital challenge for both clubs, negotiating the regular season’s highs and lows. For the Yankees, it’s a chance to show their supremacy in the city and show they still rule New York. For the Mets, it’s an opportunity to show that they are a genuine contender. And most importantly, the off-season purchases have changed them into a force to be reckoned with. Setting the tone for the vital months ahead, an excellent performance in this series might offer any squad a notable increase in confidence and morale.
With a 28-15 record, the Mets are dominating the NL East. Soto’s influence was felt right away, as he greatly helped the offensive strength of the club. Showing his consistency at the plate, he has kept a .280 batting average with 2 home runs and 9 RBIs over the last 15 games.
Conversely, the Yankees are struggling this year with a 24-18 mark. Though essential players are injured, they have managed to remain competitive in the AL East. Recently tying Babe Ruth’s record with his 321st home run in his first 1,000 games as a Yankee, Aaron Judge remains a remarkable player.
More than simply a series of games, it is a story-rich conflict. The series gains more drama since Juan Soto now wears a Mets uniform. This game is about pride, legacy, and the changing dynamics of New York baseball, not just standings. Soto’s involvement gives this historic conflict a human angle, hence turning the series into a must-see event.
With both teams competing for supremacy in the city that never sleeps, the air is going to change this weekend. This series offers not only high-stakes baseball but also a larger narrative about choices, culture, and the changing dynamics of New York’s baseball scene. Are you also excited?
The post Yankees Legend Reveals How He Already Knew Juan Soto Would Ditch Them for Mets: “I Wasn’t Surprised” appeared first on EssentiallySports.
